Learn how to make amazing New York-style Cookies at home. These easy recipes will make super thick and chunky cookies from scratch – in all of America’s favourite flavours, from chocolate chip, to red velvet and peanut butter.
After visiting New York multiple times and eating my way through their enviable cookie scene, I’ve developed some of my favourite copycat New York-style cookie recipes.
From the famous Levain Bakery Cookies on the Upper East Side to Milk Bar Bakery in East Village, I’ve seen and tasted. And my love for cookies, especially American-style cookies, runs deep.
what is a New York-style cookie?
If you’re wondering what a New York-style cookie actually is, here’s how I would describe it. Big, thick, chunky, soft on the inside, crispy on the edges, and FULL of mix-in’s – whatever they may be.
Sometimes they’re stuffed, most often they’re full of chocolate. And I can’t get enough.
While a homemade version might never be quite as good as the real thing, I guarantee that each of these cookies will give you a New York state of mind and a very satisfied appetite.
So without further ado, here are my favourite New York-style cookies that will produce big, buttery cookies every time. Each one is on high rotation in my house!